Keystone Insights Blog

Image
Expert advice and strategies for academic success and personal growth.
Image

Internal scrutiny: are trustees getting the assurance they actually need?

A trust can complete every scheduled internal scrutiny review, receive every report and submit its annual summary on time, yet still leave trustees with an incomplete picture of where the organisation is exposed. The distinction matters. Completing a programme is evidence that scrutiny has taken place. It is not, by itself, evidence that the programme has examined the risks which could do the most damage. 

The question is not whether the trust has been audited

Most audit and risk committees can describe the reviews completed during the previous year. The harder task is explaining why those areas warranted attention while others did not. A programme should reflect the risks facing the trust now, rather than becoming a standing diary of familiar assignments.

The Academy Trust Handbook 2026 requires independent scrutiny of financial and non-financial controls and risk management, with the programme informed by the trust's risk register. Meeting that requirement calls for decisions about which areas warrant attention, how deeply they should be examined and what the committee needs to learn from each review.

Consider a trust which has reviewed purchasing, payroll and expense claims in successive years. Those can all be sensible areas for scrutiny. But suppose the same trust is expanding rapidly, has recently centralised its finance team, is dependent on a handful of people to maintain essential systems and has had repeated difficulties with financial reporting. Continuing last year's programme without reconsideration may be administratively convenient. It is unlikely to provide the most useful assurance.

A risk register is not an audit plan

A risk register should inform scrutiny, but copying its highest-scored entries straight into an audit timetable is no better than recycling last year's modules. Risks described at board level are often broad: financial sustainability, safeguarding, cyber resilience, workforce capacity. A useful assignment has to turn that concern into a testable proposition.

For financial sustainability, for example, the committee may need assurance over the evidence supporting three-year forecast assumptions, the timeliness of staffing-cost updates, or the quality of challenge when a school's forecast deteriorates. Each calls for different testing. A broad review labelled "financial sustainability" can too easily cover some of these matters while leaving the most significant exposure untouched.

This is also why scope matters. A review of budget-setting controls is not an opinion on the trust's future solvency. A check of safer-recruitment files is not an assurance that the whole safeguarding culture is effective. The committee needs clarity about what was tested, what was not tested and how far a conclusion can reasonably be taken. 

Policies are promises; evidence tells you whether they are kept

A beautifully written scheme of delegation does not prevent a purchasing decision being taken outside delegated authority. A monthly reconciliation policy does not make the reconciliation timely or accurate. A documented approval workflow does not help much if the approval happens after the commitment has already been made.


Good scrutiny needs to test control design and operation. That means following actual transactions and decisions, speaking to the people carrying out the work, considering exceptions, and distinguishing a one-off mistake from a weakness in the system. An auditor who only asks whether the procedure exists is examining the trust's intentions, not necessarily its reality.

An isolated error does not automatically warrant a high-risk finding. Its significance depends on the potential consequence, the likelihood of recurrence and the reason the control failed. An impractical procedure, inadequate oversight and a one-off misunderstanding require quite different responses. Treating them alike produces more paperwork, not necessarily better control.

The board needs an assurance map, not a pile of reports

 Internal scrutiny is one source of assurance. External audit, regulatory reviews, management reporting, safeguarding audits, complaints analysis and other specialist work may each answer part of the board's questions. The Handbook explicitly expects internal scrutiny to take account of other assurance work. Duplication wastes scarce capacity; assuming another provider has covered something when they have not is worse.

An assurance map need not be elaborate. It should show the committee its principal risks, where evidence of control effectiveness comes from, when it was last tested, what its limitations are and where gaps remain. This helps trustees distinguish "we receive a report on that area" from "we have independent evidence that this control is working".

Independence needs similar care. Familiarity with the trust is valuable; the ability to challenge it is essential. Reporting lines, scope approval and the handling of conflicts must protect the scrutineer's judgement. This becomes especially important where one advisory firm provides several services to the same trust. If the provider helped design or operate a process, the committee should consider whether it is appropriate for that provider to give independent assurance over its own work.

What should an audit and risk committee receive?

A useful report should make clear the risk being examined, the evidence tested, the resulting exposure and the limitations of the review. It should also identify the action required, the person responsible and the expected timescale. Trustees should not have to piece that story together from a series of findings and appendices.

Boards should also be wary of treating a green overall rating as the ultimate objective. A scrutiny programme that never finds anything meaningful might reflect excellent controls. It might equally reflect timid scopes, predictable sampling or a reluctance to challenge. The right measure is whether the work improves the board's understanding. 

Five questions worth taking into the next committee meeting

The next committee discussion could usefully establish which material risks have not been reviewed recently; whether testing has examined controls in practice; where other sources of assurance are relied upon; how the scrutineer's independence is protected; and what improvements can be evidenced from work already completed. These are reasonable expectations of a programme that consumes both trust funding and management time.

This is not an exercise in creating more work for the finance team. It is about directing limited scrutiny time towards the issues on which trustees most need reliable evidence. 

From completing the programme to understanding the organisation

Keystone's approach begins with the trust's circumstances: strategy, current risks, changes in leadership, previous findings and the questions trustees need answered. The programme then follows those risks across finance, governance, people and operations, with an agreed scope, appropriate testing and clear reporting back to the audit and risk committee.

That requires more judgement than repeating a familiar set of modules. It also makes better use of the trust's investment. Trustees receive a clearer account of the control environment, while management has evidence it can act upon.

The measure of a good programme is not simply that the reviews were completed. It is that the board has a clearer understanding of the trust's exposure and can see where action is needed.

Keystone Knowledge | Assurance & Governance | This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. | keystoneknowledge.com

From findings to improvement: why good internal sc...
10 questions every audit and risk committee should...